Man of Steel Review

17 06 2013


I’ll cut to the chase here- Man of Steel is the best Superman movie (in my opinion), but is that really something the director wants to put on his bumper sticker? That’s like getting a “Most Normal-Looking Person” award at Wal-Mart- it’s great, but was it really that difficult? (To be fair, I haven’t seen the whole first Superman movie, but I also wouldn’t have the nostalgia factor). There’s a minimum of cheese and bad effects, not to mention no blasted super babies. I was somewhat surprised at the mixed reviews this flick’s been receiving, and the problem seems to be that everyone already had in their head what a “good Superman movie’ should be. The problem is, it can’t be  funny, serious, ponderous, action-packed, mature, or kid-friendly as they seem to want. I had an advantage, in that my only idea of a good Superman movie is “not like the other movies.” Henry Cavill seems like a good fit for the revamped Superman.

That’s not to say the script didn’t have problems. Russell Crowe‘s AI ghost was super convenient- not really a plot hole, but super convenient. How will Clark find out his true heritage, history, purpose, and be inspired by his dead father? Well, Phantom Crowe solved all those issues in an eight minute scene, and even gave Clark a suit and cape at the end. Sorta lazy writing. But hey, it’s more Russell Crowe, so how mad can you get? The film also handled Lois Lane ( Amy Adams) somewhat awkwardly. Why did Zod want her in the spaceship with Superman? Did they ever explain, or was it just to make her look a little goofy with that helmet and then break him out? But again, it’s hard to hate on Amy Adams, and any complaint for the character doesn’t stem from her performance.


May have a crush on Amy Adams.

May have a crush on Amy Adams.


Where some people started losing interest seems to be the largely CGI-generated marathon action sequences. I’m not a huge CGI fan, but c’mon, it’s a Superman film. Were they bad effects? No- not even close to the disastrous Green Lantern or even the ho-hum Hobbit work. Some successfully reached the realm of visual spectacle (the Krypton sequence in particular was gorgeous). On the other hand, these parts should leave you wanting more, not checking your watch because hasn’t this climax fight lasted longer than heartburn from Taco Bell? One reason I enjoyed most of the action parts, however, was because I got to hear Hans Zimmer go into full epic-mode with the soundtrack again.




General Zod (Michael Shannon) was effective enough, but I don’t think Heath Ledger has anything to worry about. Maybe that wasn’t a fair comparison, since Zod doesn’t have close to the complexity a villain like The Joker boasts. The whole tie-in with Superman’s father was well-used, however, and gave a bit more depth. Antje Traue as his loyal enforcer Faora-Ul was a surprisingly good villain, maybe even upstaging Michael with her creepy eyes and unassuming prowess.


She's going to beat you up.

She’s going to beat you up.


Maybe that’s the core issue for Nolan/Dark Knight fans- besides the obvious fact that he just produced, not directed the movie (instead we got Zack Snyder. Boo!), is that  Man of Steel was never intended to be The Dark Knight. Instead of a billionaire taking the law into his own hands against psychopaths, you have an alien who looks like a human flying through skyscrapers so hard that they start to collapse. What I’m saying is that by nature it’s harder to take that premise and make it relatable and relevant- yet I would argue that Man of Steel has done a great job with the first part and a good effort with the second. We feel (or should feel) the intense isolation Clark feels because he doesn’t fit in, and the raging despair when he is forced to sever his only link to Krypton and his own race. Throw in the themes of hope and sacrifice and outstanding father figures (yay Kevin Costner), and congratulations, you have the most meaningful Superman flick yet, hidden behind the layers of CGI and plot devices.


What if I told you aliens walked among us?

What if I told you aliens walked among us?




5 responses

17 06 2013

Excellent post! I always enjoy a good movie review, though I didn’t really end up liking the movie, but the premises here were interesting. If you are interested, and I am not trying to spam you here (though I’m sure that exactly what spammers say 🙂 ) , then head on over to The Disorder here on WordPress ( and check out our take on the superman movie (or just Superman in general). The rest of the site is us trying to be funny and we would really appreciate feedback if you have the time! I try to go around and comment on blogs because I know how difficult getting comments can be! Anyway, I’m sure I’ve taken up a lot of your time but I enjoyed this and just wanted to let you know!

17 06 2013

Good review. A good superhero movie, but not the best in recent memory.

18 06 2013
michael r

I could say i miss the old superman, with the cheesy soundtrack, the annoying comedy, the gay lead and his two love interests… but i’d be lying. so i will say man of steel; by far, best superman movie ever. that being said, i did have a few veals(small beefs) with it. some you’ve already mentioned. i thought amy adams was miscast. i wouldnt have given her the role just because she tried out a million times, and unless you’re previously encrushed with adams, she doesn’t force you to care about her at all. and, believe it or not, there are some actual superman fansboys out there who are wondering why lois lane is suddenly a strawberry blond. for that matter, why mr. white, wasn’t. but hey, it worked for nick fury.

but good review, and good movie overall.

18 06 2013

It was kind if random seeing her a redhead. The only bigger departure would be Mary Jane having jet black hair I guess. But hey, Amy Adams!

29 03 2016
Batman V. Superman – Movie Review | Irony Is A Poor Master

[…] and went in with lowered expectations, but still holding on to some optimism. Hey, remember when I actually enjoyed Man of Steel? Maybe they were just comparing the tone to Marvel. DC is darker. The Dark Knight was dark, but a […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: